It seems to be more of a common practice for entities to put a ban on social media for their organization. In the past we have seen several college football programs place a ban on their athletes from using Social Media and more specific Facebook and Twitter. Last season, former Texas Tech coach Mike Leach banned his Texas Tech team from using Twitter. The ban was initiated after a player tweeted about Leach being late for a team meeting following a loss to Houston.
Leach was quoted as saying this, “I think that a guy who plays college football gets enough attention,” Leach said. It’s “a bunch of narcissists that want to sit and type stuff about themselves all the time. We’ll put mirrors in some of their lockers if that’s necessary but they don’t have to Twitter.” I like Mike Leach as a coach and his quirky personality, but his comment reveals his oblivious naivety to Social Media.
This year’s college football Cinderella team Boise State has also been placed on a Twitter ban by their head coach Chris Peterson. Peterson stated, “It’s just a distraction that we just don’t really need to have right now. There’s plenty of time in their lifetime for Twitter.”
I believe it’s important for coaches and leaders to put certain rules, expectations and curfews in place to put their team or organizations in the situation to be successful. Seriously, some of these bans are ridiculous. This week Harrisburg University of Science and Technology is going one step further with a “social-media blackout.” Kicking off this Monday, the Pennsylvania institution will block Facebook, Twitter, AOL Instant Messenger, and MySpace on the campus network for a week. This blackout will affect faculty, staff and students. “Telling students to imagine a time before Facebook is like telling them to imagine living in a world with dinosaurs,” said Eric D. Darr, Harrisburg’s executive vice president and provost.
Vice-President Darr insisted the restricted access wasn’t censorship. “We’re not denying students, staff, and faculty the right to connect to Facebook since the university network is only one avenue to get to these sites,” he said. “They can drive down the road to a place with wireless if they really want.” Well vice-president Darr, if they can just go down the street why go through the trouble with the blackout?
I’m sure Mike Leach, Chris Peterson, The University of Harrisburg and countless others which have implemented such policies are well intentioned, they may just be a little uninformed. The question I have for those people placing any sort of A Ban On Social Media is, “Are you placing a ban on any other sort of media?” How about a ban on computers, televisions, faxes, mobile devices, iPods, iPads… Those are all forms of media and all can be distractions like anything else. The most effective way to monitor any form of media is to set clear expectations and rules for behavior.
Again, Media Is Not The Problem, I Repeat – Media Is Not The Problem… Media is neutral, the only problem with media is People and Perception. It cracks me up when I hear people say that you shouldn’t use Social Media a certain way and you shouldn’t tweet this or post that. The most important concept to recognize about Social Media is the “Social” part. The bottom line is that we are all social beings and we all socialize in different manners; therefore we all use Social Media in different manners.
Don’t put A Ban On Social, instead embrace it for what it is. It’s the fabric of today’s connections, news and socialization and it’s not going anywhere. Social Media Bans are about as effective as the Street Preacher with the bullhorn outside of a nightclub yelling that everyone is going to hell — not effective at all.
A Ban On Social Media… I don’t think so!
What do you think about Social Media Bans and social Media Restrictions?